How to evaluate a journal article. How to evaluate journal articles and websites 2019-01-12
How to evaluate a journal article Rating:
5,4/10
604
reviews
How to Evaluate an Article
The whole point of the is to have objective third parties who are experts in the relevant fields critically examine the work, and these fake journals distort or completely evade that process. Before you cite an article, take some time to review who wrote it, when it was written, how the author -- or authors -- conducted the research and where the actual study was published. Or there will be holdings information from our catalog indicating print or microfilm format, years of coverage, and location. This can lead you to other sources. Point out both strengths and weaknesses, and propose alternative solutions instead of focusing only on weaknesses. Rather, they are guidelines to help you judge how confident you should be in the results and how much time you need to invest in critically analyzing the paper.
How to Review a Journal Article: 13 Steps (with Pictures)
However, be cautious: some articles may be highly cited because their findings are contenscious! If the paper was written by respected experts in their fields, published in a high impact factor journal, and makes sense in light of what other researchers have found, then I would probably give the authors the benefit of the doubt and assume that they knew what they were doing. Are tables and figures purposeful or redundant? Sometimes these are problems of research quality that the authors were unable to anticipate i. Come up with a thesis that concisely summarizes your evaluation, compose your review, and include specific examples that back up your claims. They are full of jargon and complex terms. Where are his or her allegiances? Skim the article to get a feel for its organization, read it multiple times, and jot down notes and comments during the process. Evaluating Journal Articles Articles in databases have already been published, and have gone through a review and editing process, unlike web sites. Or is it colourful and flashy with a lot of graphics and advertisements? Journals associated with professional organizations are also a safe bet because they tend to be high-quality.
Step 2: Critically evaluate the main journal article and its component parts
The database will give you the author, title, name of periodical, volume, pages and date of publication for each article, which is called the citation. Since these research limitations are often identified during the research process or once the data has been collected, these are most often acknowledged and explained in the Research Limitations section of the Discussion or Conclusion sections of the main journal article, although the section is only infrequently entitled, Research Limitations. ¿La investigación original, es una revisión de la investigación previa o un texto informativo? Determine if the sources it references are authoritative, how well its literature review summarizes sources, and whether the sources situate the article in a field of research or simply drop well-known names. You can also re-sort your database results in order of those most highly cited and therefore, potentially most influential. In the demonstrations found below, we'll follow the efforts of Anthony Gomez, a student writing a research project about the use of service learning in college classrooms.
So you should always read scientific papers carefully and critically evaluate whether or not the paper can be trusted regardless of whether or not the paper agrees with your preconceived views. Also, in many cases grants simply provide research funding, not salaries. However, also check the dates of the references at the end of a document. If we don't own it, it will take more time to get your hands on the source. If all else fails, check Google for a refutation I am extremely hesitant to include this, and I encourage you never to rely on it after all, it directly conflicts with my first point , but if nothing else, before you blindly believe an abstract or blog about a paper, get on Google and see if people have objectively critiqued it.
This article has over 36,032 views and 96% of readers who voted found it helpful, earning it our reader-approved status. Therefore, in this post, I am going to provide you with a rough guide for understanding scientific results. Please note that this is only one example of the format of a scholarly article. ¿Son claras y lucen profesionalmente? They should always build on existing work and back up their claims using what other researchers have found. Is the argument or presentation understandable? If you are doing a survey of popular culture, for example, popular magazines would be a useful primary source. Step 4 Find the journal's impact factor score. So, if you have an extraordinary result that is going to be of wide interest to many people, then you typically publish it in a high impact journal, but if your results are of fairly narrow interest, then it will be published in a low impact journal.
Does the interpretation arise logically from the data or is it too far-fetched? ¿Ha ganado reconocimientos y honores? Contrast this to a news feature, which pulls together results and ideas from other researchers' work. Select a review article on a topic that interests you and that is written clearly so you can understand it. After writing your first draft, check for typos and make sure your grammar and punctuation are correct. Evaluate the Text After you have read the article and answered the questions in the previous section, you should have a good understanding of the research undertaken. Use the answers to the questions in Evaluate the Text to develop this section.
Will this matter for your topic? High impact journals are very widely read and cited, whereas low impact journals are not read by many researchers. Date— research in many subjects requires the most current information available. How did each result contribute to answering the question or testing the hypothesis raised in the introduction? In this particular case, the article was published Medical Veritas which, as I previously explained, was an extremely biased and agenda driven pseudo-journal. A well-researched, well-written article is not going to be helpful if it does not address the topic at hand. What was the objective of the study? The references in this list should be in sufficient quantity and be appropriate for the content.
These include newspapers, popular magazines, and academic or scholarly journals. Go to Academic Search Premier and click on Publications at the top of the screen. · Methods : Articles in the sciences and social sciences typically include descriptions of the research methodology. However, not all journals are created equal; you should try to find journals that are peer-reviewed for the best sources of information, as these will be more reliable than other journals. The can also be used to filter and locate journals based upon publisher policies on these key components. Does all the information lead coherently to the purpose of the study? What kind of data can be obtained using each technique? The main reason for this is that there can be problems with the data that was collected e.
