Was stalin an effective leader. Was Stalin an effective leader? 2019-01-11

Debate Issue: Was Stalin a good leader?

For the begginning of that time he shared the power with others. That's not a small feat. Lenin, who was leader of the Communists during the , admired Stalin for the hard work he did for the party. I accept your debate, I will be laying out a simple argument here in the first round. As a whole, I agree with my opponent that the purging of military personnel was a mistake on Stalin's part, the issue is not as significant as my opponent tries to make it out to be, without showing any really evidence. By 1929, he was the only one left with any power in the government although he was still subject to being removed by vote of the Politburo of the Central Committee.

Was Stalin a good leader

It is examples of that I am speaking of. He is well loved by most Russians Most Americans wouldn't ever know how great a leader he was and led the Union to end World War 2 as one of two world superpowers. Stalinwas a subordinate to Lenin at the time so he was not a leader atall. Stalin also placed his supporters in important positions. A smallish child, he was teased by other childrenafter smallpox left his face scarred. Its remit covered politics, security, international subversion, culture, economics, ideology, diplomacy and the military. But your site totally came to my rescue and helped me out of a bind.

What made Adolf Hitler a charismatic leader?

Anti-semitism was nothing new in Germany, especially among the middle class, but Hitler propelled this notion by persistently scapegoating the Jews for all the wrongs within German society and by blaming them for the humiliating loss of the First World War. . Also at the end of World War 2 he brought the iron curtain over east berlin which resulted in i. Life of Joseph Stalin Dzhugashvili was raised by his mother because his father was analcoholic. I scored an 94 and was very pleased. It was his military buildup and great training of the Red Army thatsucceeded in winning half of the European Theater of Operations.

Joesph Stalin, A Good or Bad Leader? free essay, term paper and book report

Stalin was an effective ruler in the views of some, but the methods he used and the changes he made were at the expense of his country and his people. He also increased transportation be building many new railroads all across the country, including the Turkenstan-Siberian railway. Dissid … ents were sent togulags in Siberia, and in general he tended to more or less bullyhis people into compliance. By putting himself forward as their spokesman he transformed the Soviet Union into a state whose nature was at odds with the one that Lenin and Trotsky had in mind in the years after the October 1917 Revolution. Tans lecture, Maastricht University: Laurence Rees on the The Charisma of Adolf Hitler, October 2012 Unwavering conviction In the 1920s, only a minority of Germans sympathised with Hitler, as became clear with his failed putsch in 1923 and his defeat in the elections of 1928, where he obtained only 2,6 percent of the votes.

Was Stalin a good leader for the USSR? : AskHistorians

Stalin was General Secretary of the Communist Party and began placing people loyal to him in important posts i … n government and on the Central Committee of the Party. Khrushchev cleverly out maneuvered other top Party officials, andbuilt his own power base. However, even this was not enough. In the end, Hitler vs Stalin is like the Tyson vs. Unfortunately, with no firm leadership from Stalin, financial sanctions against free socialist world took their toll, and neoimperialists menaged to enslave Eastern Europe again, at least temporarily, causing living standards to fall dramatically in the 90s.

Was Stalin a good leader for the USSR? : AskHistorians

Stalin was the leader of the U. After the war, Russia became leader in space technology, as Stalin continued to place focus on science, education and health care free for all, enjoying improved life and well being in prosperous and industrious Soviet Union. This might be my fault in that I didn't clarify. Stalin took revenge for that. See the Related Links for Joseph Stalin for more.

Was Joseph Stalin a good leader of the USSR during World War 2

I would suggest he was evil and ineffective. The war ended before his troops could invade Japan. Counter Arguments: 1 Agricultural Collectivization My opponent summarizes the entire process, but it all boils down the fact that collectivization caused a massive famine Holodor. It was the turning point of the war and from then on the Red Army started marching towards the west. Between 1913 and 1940, oil production increased from nine to 35 million tons; coal from 29 to 164; pig iron from 4 to 15; steel from 4 to 18; machine tools from 1000 to 48,000 units, tractors from 0 to over 500,000; harvestor combines from 0 to 153,500; electrical power output from two billion kWh to 50 billion; and the value of industrial output from 11 billion rubles to more than 100 billion by 1938. Exact dates, even if they do exist, are not reliable.

Was Joseph Stalin an effective leader?

Tighter cultural controls, Zhdanov and Non-Cosmopolitanism. Joseph Stalin was a horrible leader of the soviet union because he sacrificed millions of innocent lives in order to increase heavy industry in Russia. Rumors say he might have been poisoned. Stalin was first and foremost out for Stalin. A network of spies collected information from all over the world. He eventually succeeded in having … Trotsky expelled from the party and later the entire country , He then repeated the process to eliminate all threats until he was made the absolute ruller of the Soviet Union. The war between Hitler and Stalin was the largest war to ever be fought.

Was Stalin an effective leader? by Charlotte Ellis on Prezi

Although he was still unable to establish a personal contact with people, large crowds did not hinder him. . I still think Stalin's disregard for democracy and the value of human life to be inexcusable. And the debate essentially ended with two rounds left. Joseph Stalin killed 56,000,000 people 7,000 men, 7,000 soldiersand 42,000 women and children his children and wife killed themselfs and the soviet unions dictator. I await my opponent's response. My friends and I had made sure to arrive on time and we were lucky to find a tiny spot on the stairs.

Was Stalin a good leader? : communism

Their son Yakov was never really close to his father. Loss only strengthened his conviction and he would share his ideas with increased vigour with everyone who crossed his path. He put accent on education and development, and soon masses of Soviet citizens rised from poverty and illiteracy to become the most educated nation on Earth. Now for the other question: Was he effective at advancing Soviet infastructure? Basically, with foresight and iron-fisted tactics, Stalin created a superpower out of a nation that had been seen as poor and weak for hundreds of y … ears. These people ought to be considered. Then Russia had the second best economy in the world at that time but it wasn't worth all the sacrifice. Entering a seminary and studying for theOrthodox priesthood was one of the few ways the son of poorpeasants could get an education in the 19th Century Russian Empire.